Amalgam .....is it safe to use ?
For a very long period of time amalgam has been used as a filling
to restore carious teeth (especially the posterior teeth). The cost and
durability of Amalgam made it a very popular filling. Around thirty years
ago many dentists started to debate about the safety of this material since
mercury (a very harmful ingredient when used separately) is used in it.
Recently alternative materials have appeared in the market
that can substitute the amalgam, however those materials came along with an
increase in the cost of fillings and decreased durability. Those facts left
the dentists in a dilemma of weather to use amalgam or other alternatives
for filling a cavity.
Recently experts from around the world participated in a World Health
Organization (WHO) consultation in Geneva. Five important issues concerning
amalgam were identified, and a statement on dental amalgam was unanimously
approved by the participating groups.
A Statement endorsed by the FDI/World Dental Federation has
the following five issues reported verbatim:
The Use of Dental Amalgams
Dental amalgam is a frequently used material for restoring
decayed teeth. It has been used successfully for more than a century and its
quality has improved over the years. Amalgam restorations are durable and
cost-effective; they are, however, not tooth-colored. While much research
has been devoted to the development of dental restorative materials, there
is currently no direct filling material that has the wide indications for
use, ease of handling and good physical properties of dental amalgam. The
restorative materials currently available as alternatives to dental amalgam
significantly increase the cost of dental care.
Safety of Dental Amalgam
Dental amalgam restorations are considered safe, but
components of amalgam and other restorative materials may, in rare
instances, cause local side effects or allergic reactions. The small amount
of mercury released from amalgam restorations, especially during placement
and removal, has not been shown to cause other adverse health effects.
Because of concerns over the adverse effects of mercury, some
patients, with or without symptoms, may request the removal of their amalgam
restorations. While there have been a number of case studies and informal
reports, no controlled studies have been published demonstrating systemic
adverse effects from amalgam restorations.
Therefore, after a comprehensive oral examination and appropriate
dental treatment, these patients should be considered for referral to other
health care professionals for diagnosis and treatment if symptoms persist.
Occupational Risk to Oral Health Personnel
A potential health risk to oral health personnel from mercury
exposure exists if working conditions are not properly organized. The
application of proper mercury hygienic requirements, together with the
monitoring of mercury vapors in the work environment in dental clinics, will
significantly reduce mercury exposure.
Environmental Concerns
Mercury used in dentistry may contaminate the environment via the
disposal of waste products from dental clinics. Equipment is available to
collect metallic waste generated during amalgam placement and removal.
Appropriate collection and recycling technology is also available to reduce
mercury pollution of the environment, including pollution from crematoria.
Public Opinion and Mass Media
Today, there is a considerable exchange of information on dental
amalgam around the world. For environmental reasons, some countries are
restricting all uses of mercury, including dental amalgam. Due to publicity
in the mass media, however, the situation in those countries which have
undertaken restrictive action is often misinterpreted, leading numerous
inquiries about the safety of dental amalgam and a demand for the removal of
amalgam fillings.
However, adverse biological reactions to the material do
occasionally occur and they must be treated on an individual basis. The WHO
recognizes the importance of continued monitoring of safety and
effectiveness of all dental restorative materials.